A glass that used to be half-full, shattered on the floor, is still a broken glass.
“What does not kill you makes you stronger” is often a sentence said by people who would also tell you that “everything happens for a reason” or that “you’ve learned a valuable life lesson here”. If I understand why people are trying to see the good even in the worst situations, sometimes, silence is better than people trying to prove a positive point. Such as explaining why the broken glass lying on the floor might have been half-full before being shattered. I mean, “if you really put your heart into it”. However the glass was before being broken; it is still broken. So be careful with your little feet and the pieces lying everywhere, because it might not go along with the general opinion, but I genuinely think that what does not kill you does not always make you stronger.
Sometimes, it simply hurts you like a b**ch.
Does an experience necessarily have to improve you?
I do understand the principle of that saying, like a rule of life some would live by. It is based on solid grounds and says how adversity can teach you resilience, awareness, patience, independence, and perspective. It also says trauma can give you a thicker skin and help you become a stronger person as you go through life. But does an experience necessarily have to improve you? Some of us go through trauma, failure, grief, rejection or hardship and come out with wounds, not wisdom. Because survival is not the same as growth. Yes, you went through some very traumatic experiences, and you’ve survived them. But I am not sure surviving something gives you more strength. It gives you more scars, more fear and that very iron-y taste in your mouth that stays with you, whether you drink — maybe from that used-to-be half-full glass, who knows — to wash it off, or decide to keep it with you as a reminder of what happened to you.
I doubt people experiencing civil wars for years feel stronger when/if they go back to any form of normal life afterwards. People losing their jobs, their partners, their houses, people being assaulted, betrayed, lied to, manipulated, abused.
Holding on to the silver lining sometimes looks like the golden ticket out
But aren’t all the famous sayings some kind of silver linings we are desperately holding on to? Like a form of reinsurance we are grabbing when feeling vulnerable. A pick-me-up sentence we tell ourselves and the people who need it, in order to feel better.
“Plenty of fish in the sea”
“It happens when you least expect it”
“What goes around comes around” — I mean, this one has to be true because Justin Timberlake gave us a great song based on that so…
“What does not kill you makes you stronger”
“Making you stronger” versus deciding into what to pour your strengths afterwards
I keep reading some very encouraging conclusions from people who have been through hell and back. How they have learned, healed, and sometimes even are grateful for who they became because of previous events. Not grateful for the trauma they had to survive, but for the new version of themselves that was born after the previous version died somewhere in the process. We all face great pain in our lives, some of them being so overwhelming they take away with them a version of us we will never get back. The version who trusted fully, the innocence, the thought of a world where there is good in people, despite what they have been through. And if I don’t think that what does not kill us does not always make us stronger, I do believe there is strength coming from this great pain. The strength to keep on going, doing good, to keep on hoping for the best, to love, have empathy, give back and to always, always choose kindness over anything else.
Because what does not kill us does not always make us stronger, but it surely always crash-tests our core values.




